Featured image of 2019 CraftBot 3 Review – The Supervisor Needs Supervision
Let's Get Crafty

2019 CraftBot 3 Review – The Supervisor Needs Supervision

Rating:

Picture of All3DP
by All3DP
Apr 11, 2019

2019 CraftBot 3 Review – The Supervisor Needs Supervision

Could the CraftBot 3 be a worthy entry to the dual extrusion market or does it lack the reliability to truly stand out? Check out our review to see how it holds up.

Hailing from Hungary, the 3D printer manufacturer CraftUnique has earned a first-rate reputation for manufacturing reliable and easy-to-use desktop 3D printers. In fact, their flagship CraftBot Plus was awarded by 3D Hubs as the Best Plug N’ Play 3D Printer in 2016, 2017, and 2018.

The company is now expanding its reach into the realm of dual extrusion. Cue the CraftBot 3 – also known as The Supervisor – a dual extrusion 3D printer that has a filament monitoring system, high-grade components, and oh so much more.

Listed at $2199, the CraftBot 3 offers some distinct features usually reserved for 3D printers at a higher price range. Do the flashy features live up to the hype? Does this machine offer an alternative to its higher-priced peers?  Here’s our review of the CraftBot 3’s performance and whether it’s worth your money.

CraftBot 3

Product image of CraftBot 3 (Dual Extrusion 3D Printer)

CraftBot 3 Review Verdict

Pros

  • Fairly quiet
  • Pause or restart prints after a power outage
  • WiFi connectivity to CraftApp and CraftWare/PrintWare
  • Mirror, parallel settings let you quickly print two identical models at the same time
  • Filament monitoring system pauses prints when filament has run out and can identify and solve clogs

Cons

  • Mediocre prints and frequent print failure
  • Dual extrusion wastes a lot of filament and is unreliable
  • CraftWare slicer software isn’t the greatest
  • Bed leveling is difficult, especially because of the dual extruders, and prints don’t stick well (or are very difficult to remove once they’re done)
  • The design makes it difficult to see prints at the beginning because of a wide metal panel at the top

We really wanted to like this printer. The CraftBot 3 offers many useful features that would serve any professional well, there’s a whole slew of exciting specs that – especially at this price point – make it an attractive choice.

Features like dual extrusion are exciting to use and work with – and the printer lets you customize the settings for each extruder so you can work with two different filament types simultaneously.

But the reality is that these features mean nothing if they don’t work, or only sometimes work or just don’t work well enough. The CraftBot 3’s print quality is simply not good enough to make it anyone’s first choice.

Don’t get us wrong — this printer offers cool perks like an LED indicator that changes colors to indicate printing status and others. But when it really comes down to whether it can perform against other dual extrusion printers, or just perform at all, it’s simply not in the same league as a pricier, but more reliable BCN3D Sigma R19, for example.

CraftBot 3 Review Design

DUAL EXTRUSION

Similarly to the BCN3D Sigma 3D printer range, the CraftBot 3 utilizes an Independent Dual Extrusion (IDEX) system, which entails two print heads that operate independently from one another. This allows users to print two objects at once or add PVA support material to produce more complex parts. The CraftBot 3 automatically cleans the nozzles when the print heads swap places by building a hollow filament tower to ensure excess filament material doesn’t muddy up the surface of your print.

FILAMENT MONITORING SYSTEM

Aside from the dual extrusion system, the CraftBot 3 also contains a number of other impressive features. One highlight is the new filament monitoring system (FMS) that keeps track of filament consumption, provides troubleshooting when a filament jam is detected, and also sends messages to the user via the CraftApp app when manual intervention is required.

BUILD

The CraftBot 3 has a sizable build volume of 374 x 250 x 250mm (270 x 250X 250mm for dual extrusion and 187 x 250 x 250mm for multi-part printing) and is capable of printing at a layer resolution of 50 microns when using the 0.25mm nozzle. And, if you’re concerned about this printer keeping you awake throughout the night, rest assured that the CraftBot 3 motor control makes this 3D printer quite quiet during operation.

In terms of the touchscreen, which is large and colourful, once you figure out what all the icons mean it is very easy to use.

Priced in the $2,000 range, the CraftBot 3 still manages to boast a professional-grade design. It has a full-metal hotend that can reach temperatures as high as 300°C, expanding the range of compatible materials far beyond your average PLA. It’s also equipped with high-accuracy ball screws that are supposed to improve overall print quality and performance.

HEATED BED

The CraftUnique team has put a fair amount of thought into the heated bed. Not only is it designed to prevent warping and sticking, but it can also be quickly removed once your print is complete.

However, the bed has the dual annoyance of being hard for prints to stick to — which requires copious amounts of glue to fix — and then being extremely difficult to pop prints off of once they are done.

The material coating the top of the bed is also easy to accidentally scrape off when dealing with a particularly firmly attached print, leaving gashes on your otherwise flat surface.

CraftBot 3 Review Printing

Image of CraftBot 3 Review: Printing
None of these prints were particularly impressive, unfortunately. (Source: All3DP)

We started our CraftBot 3 adventure off with a classic print: The Benchy. It turns out printing in doubles is twice as fun. The prints were fairly decent, but where the machine struggled was with overhangs and bridging. This issue would become more apparent the more we printed.

If you look at the front window of this Benchy, you’ll see that the CraftBot 3 wasn’t quite able to handle the bridging, though the print overall isn’t bad. (Source: All3DP)

It was fun finding models for dual extrusion prints to test this printer. What was less fun was first figuring out how to get our prints to stick to the hotbed.

After a few prints came unstuck midway through printing and failed, we realized the solution is a lot of glue. Though our first successful print, Left Shark, was fairly decent, its success was tough to replicate. In fact, this printer’s performance was consistently inconsistent.

The CraftBot struggled with the Left Shark, but ultimately succeeded on its third attempt. (Source: All3DP)

One of the main issues we had was with leveling the bed properly for prints. At its price range, automatic bed leveling would be preferred, however, with this machine, the pressure is on you to get it exactly right — a feat complicated by the dual extruders.

Wanting to test its extrusion abilities, we printed two Eiffel Towers simultaneously – one in gold and one in silver. Though it did print two towers – in the end – the result was a hot mess of stray strands of filament everywhere. It turns out its retraction abilities leave a lot to be desired.

If you’re Parisian, we would like to take this opportunity to apologize for this print. (Source: All3DP)

When using both extruders, and not at the same time, the printer builds a hollow filament tower to get rid of any filament blobs that accumulate on the end of the nozzle while it’s idling. This works, for the most part, but has many downfalls. Not only does it waste a bit of filament, but when doing a large build, the tower can get quite tall and unstable. Midway through the print, the tower snapped in half – jeopardizing 20 hours of work with a remaining 20-30 left to go.

This ‘Leaning Tower of Pisa’ was created automatically while using the dual extruders. Unfortunately, it broke midway through the print. (Source: All3DP)

We ended up taping a metal rod to it to try and keep it upright and together so the entire print wouldn’t fail or become more sloppy than it already was. And it worked, but if we hadn’t been watching the printer in action right when this happened, we wouldn’t have been so lucky.

As mentioned earlier, a big issue with the printer was its ability to handle overhang and bridging. On a cheaper machine, this would be more understandable, but for a printer marketed as for professionals, it was disappointing. Though it got through prints, there was nothing it made that wowed us.

The CraftBot 3 scored 19.5 points out of a possible 30 on the Autodesk Kickstarter test. (Source: All3DP)

Our final print, the Autodesk Kickstarter test, looks at an FDM printer’s precision – read more about it here. The CraftBot 3 achieved the following results:

  • Dimensional Accuracy: 5 of 5 points (24.92 / 19.94 / 14.94 / 10.08 / 4.94)
  • Fine Flow Control: 2.5 of 5 points (the spikes were printed to their full height, but we encountered some stringing at the top)
  • Fine Negative Features: 5 of 5 points (all pins were removable by hand)
  • Overhangs: 2 of 5 points (30°, 20° and 15° overhangs showed some minor irregularities)
  • Bridging: 0 of 5 points (no bridges contacted the surface beneath them)
  • XY Resonance: 2.5 of 2.5 points (no ringing detectable)
  • Z-Axis Alignment: 2.5 of 2.5 points (no layer registration effect visible)

Overall, the printer scored 19.5 out of a possible 30 points. (For comparison, a Prusa i3 MK3 scores 22.5 on this test.)

Ultimately, because the prints were generally mediocre, we did not bother testing the printer out with other materials.

CraftBot 3 Review Software: CraftWare, PrintWare & CraftApp

Image of CraftBot 3 Review: Software: CraftWare, PrintWare & CraftApp
CraftWare isn't the greatest slicer, but it definitely has some cool features. (Source: All3DP)

CraftWare, CraftUnique’s free slicer software that it boasts is “compatible not only with CraftBot, but every RepRap 3D printer operating with Gcode”, does not live up to its marketing hype.

In fact, we’d suggest the name CrashWare instead.

Though it offers many handy features and really lets you customize your print within the expert mode, it is not as easy-to-use as claimed and feels a little clunky and frustrating.

One of the features we liked was how when slicing the model, it gives you a lot of freedom to really customize the print. It also gives a visual so you can see exactly what the settings you pick will look like and it explains what each function does and how it affects the quality of the print.

But, we ran into a lot of issues with CraftWare. After troubleshooting with CraftUnique, we were told the reason some of our prints were crashing was because the default setting for ‘Island Hopping’ is set to ‘Balanced’. This causes a crash on certain models, like the Kickstarter Autodesk test, for example.

The solution is to switch it to ‘Shortest’ or ‘Straight’ in the expert slicer mode on the ‘Advanced’ tab, but CraftUnique says the bug should also be fixed in the next two months when they release an update to CraftWare.

The CraftApp, though, is fairly decent. It shows you how the prints are going in your queue and also lets you know if anything goes awry.

In fact, at one point it posted a bold ‘WARNING’ and stated a ‘filament flow error is detected in Head 2!’ It was right. And when I went to check on the printer it was valiantly trying to unclog itself. Bless. A neat feature that actually seems to work, though it is suspect how often the extruders clog.

CraftBot 3 Review Final Thoughts

This printer offers a lot of features that would be very useful in a professional setting — if the print quality was more consistent.

Its lower price relative to other dual extrusion printers using IDEX technology, like the BCN3D Sigma printers, is a definite draw, but this machine comes with a lot of hassle and time spent sweet talking it and troubleshooting. If a pricier (and better performing) machine is absolutely out of the question for you, but you think you have the time and patience to fiddle around and need prosumer features and workflows, then the CraftBot 3 could be a good option.

But be aware — this is a finicky beast.

CraftBot 3 Review Tech Specs

Image of CraftBot 3 Review: Tech Specs

Here are the cold, hard technical specifications for the CraftBot 3 3D printer:

Printer Specs

  • Printing technology: Fused Filament Fabrication (FFF)
  • Build volume: 374 x 250 x 250 mm
  • Layer resolution: 100 micron (ultra) / 200 micron (high) / 300 micron (medium)
  • Position precision: X,Y: 4 micron / Z: 2 micron
  • Filament diameter: 1.75 mm
  • Nozzle diameter: Includes nozzle kit with 0.25mm, 0.4 mm, 0.6mm, 0.8mm nozzles
  • Print speed: 50-200 mm/s
  • Connectivity: USB cable, USB pen drive, WiFi

Software

  • Software package: CraftWare
  • File types: OBJ/STL/CWPRJ
  • Supports: Windows 7 and above

Physical dimensions

  • Frame dimensions: 57 x 44 x 48.8 cm
  • Shipping box: 70 x 58 x 66 cm
  • Weight: 32 kg
  • Shipping weight: 36 kg
  • Ambient temperature: 15-32 °C
  • Storage temperature: 0-32 °C
  • Operating nozzle temperature: 180-300 °C
  • Operating heated build plate temperature: 50-110°C

CraftBot 3 Review Where to Buy

The CraftBot 3 is currently available on the Matterhackers webshop. You can also purchase the CraftBot 3 3D printer directly from the CraftBot website or from the global network of official CraftBot partners.

CraftBot 3

Product image of CraftBot 3 (Dual Extrusion 3D Printer)

License: The text of "2019 CraftBot 3 Review – The Supervisor Needs Supervision" by All3DP is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Subscribe to updates from All3DP

You are subscribed to updates from All3DP

You can’t subscribe to updates from All3DP. Learn more… Subscribe

You can’t subscribe to updates from All3DP. Learn more…

Recommended for you